Skip to content
Author
PUBLISHED: | UPDATED:
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Think the swashbuckling Capt. Jack Aubrey of “Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World” owns the high seas? Think again. Capt. Horatio Hornblower, who stars in a new adventure on A&E

Tuesday and Wednesday, is also a worthy British seafaring hero (see review on Page 3). How do the fictional Napoleonic War adventures stack up? We signed on with both and file this report:

– – –

WHO RATES HIGHER?

CAPTAIN’S HUNK-O-SITY

* `MASTER’: Quite manly, even in knee breeches.

`HORATIO’: A bit too stern to be truly studly.

HAPLESS MIDSHIPMAN

`MASTER’: Midshipman Hollom, who sailors believe is bad luck.

* `HORATIO’: Midshipman Hammond, who can’t seem to summon his nerve.

PESSIMISTIC QUOTE FROM CRUSTY SEA SALT

`MASTER’: Creepy old sailor who calls the French Acheron “a devil ship, I tell you — it’s leading us into a trap.”

* `HORATIO’: A “bloody frog” comes on board, and sailor Styles mutters “strangers on board ill luck doth afford.”

BIGGEST DISCOVERY

* `MASTER’: Dr. Maturin, a naturalist, discovers flightless birds in Galapagos Islands.

`HORATIO’: Hornblower discovers that Styles isn’t much of a cook.

GRUESOME SCENE

`MASTER’: Dr. Maturin performing surgery — on himself.

* `HORATIO’: Horatio proposing marriage to his whiny amour.

FLOG-O-METER

`MASTER’: A sailor is flogged for not showing proper respect to a superior.

* `HORATIO’: Hotheaded Styles is flogged for setting the ship’s kitchen on fire.

SEXY SCENE

* `MASTER’: The gaze between Aubrey and a Brazilian girl is brief but hot.

`HORATIO’: The scenes between Hornblower and his love interest are all wet.

QUOTE

* `MASTER’: To Dr. Maturin: “Name a shrub for me, something prickly and hard to eradicate.”

`HORATIO’: “We are the king’s officers, we have a duty to do and we’ve not a thought to spare for anything else.”

VILLAIN

`MASTER’: The enigmatic Acheron.

* `HORATIO’: A wily Irishman (or two).

THE VERDICT

`MASTER’: Though a masterful production, “Master” left us a little cold.

* `HORATIO’: A lively “Horatio” wins by a yardarm.