Citing the economic motives of the church, lack of biblical underpinnings and the disturbing phenomenon of clergy abuse, Elyse Krug Miller, in less than 300 words, argues for eliminating celibacy from priestly ordination.
Due to space limitations, refuting each of Miller’s shaky and questionable assertions is not possible here.
Let one clarifying word, however, serve as my challenge to Miller: “vow.”
Confusing a sacred promise (vow) with one’s “right” to be sexually active radically distorts the true end of celibacy, which is its quintessential connection to the church’s sacramental life.
Candidates for the priesthood and religious life willingly and freely vow themselves to lead lives of chastity and obedience for the sake of continuing the mission of the church. Religious communities take this one step further, making a vow of poverty.
The few who break their vows always make the evening news; the many who keep them, however, serve as wonderful role models for the faithful.
Miller has obfuscated the gift that celibacy has been and can continue to be for our broken and hurt world.
