Whether old or young, big or small, every dog needs a well-fitting collar. They serve as a point of control, contain important information and help keep the dog safe when out in the world. While collars come in various types, the most common option is the basic flat collar, which features a simple fastener and sturdy D-ring.
Basic dog collars are relatively thin yet durable, offering easy usage and plenty of aesthetic options. The Max and Neo Nylon Dog Collar demonstrates the high quality possible from basic dog collars; finding the best one means seeking out quality materials and an appropriate size for your dog.
What to know before you buy a basic dog collar
Material
Basic dog collars are made in a few different materials. Nylon is among the most popular, as it’s cheap, lightweight and offered in a range of colors and patterns. However, nylon can be difficult to clean, particularly when it comes to stubborn odors, and it may wear down more quickly over time than other materials.
Neoprene is similar to nylon but offers more durability. It provides more comfort to the dog and doesn’t break down or fade with prolonged exposure to water, which is especially useful for adventurous dogs. It does, however, come at a higher price.
Leather is also an option, though it requires proper care to last long and doesn’t do well with prolonged water exposure. Faux leather is an eco-friendly alternative, however, it typically won’t last as long.
Size
Many basic dog collars are adjustable, but that range only goes so far. To find the right fit, measure the circumstance of your dog’s neck just below the ears. This can be done using a flexible tape measure; you can also use a piece of yarn or string and then lay that out straight against a ruler. The collar should be snug, but not so tight that it’s uncomfortable or restricts movement. Generally, you should be able to fit two fingers under the collar and between the skin.
Fasteners
Most basic dog collars feature a simple snap fastener. These feature two plastic pieces that quickly click together and are easily undone by pressing the sides together. These tend to be fairly durable, though they can weaken in extreme cold. The quick-release feature is convenient for owners and may be especially useful during any potential emergencies.
The alternative is a buckle clip. These are less common and popular, and work similar to a belt buckle. They take time to put on and take off but offer increased reliability and durability.
Basic dog collar features
Martingale
The martingale collar adds an important feature to the basic collar that makes it ideal for training dogs that pull. It features a second loop where a leash is attached, and as the dog pulls, the loop tightens slightly. Owners can adjust how much the collar tightens so that it doesn’t hurt the dog, but does keep them from slipping out of the collar.
Colors and patterns
Basic dog collars are offered in a wide range of designs. Many color options are available, as are various patterns, such as floral or camouflage. Others may boast pictures or even characters from popular culture. The look of the collar won’t affect its function, however, some nylon options may fade or bleed color over time.
Reflective
Some basic dog collars feature a reflective liner to increase visibility when it’s dark outside. This is useful for those who will be walking their dogs after the sun goes down, particularly in northern locales when dusk may come early in the winter. While the reflective liner provides some visibility, the owner may want to supplement it with a reflective coat, leash or LED collar.
Basic dog collar cost
Basic dog collars are relatively inexpensive, with most costing between $8 and $20. Price will increase along with size.
Basic dog collar FAQ
Should I keep the collar on at all times?
A. Some dog owners remove the collar when their pup is inside. It prevents potential injury should the collar get caught on something, particularly if the dog will be left unsupervised. What’s more, prolonged collar use irritates fur around the neck, so removing the collar gives the area a chance to breathe. Just don’t forget to put the collar back on when it’s time to go out.
Are basic dog collars good for walking dogs?
A. While your dog should always wear a collar when they are on a walk, most dogs are better served by being walked with a harness. Dogs that pull or react on a walk can hurt themselves when a leash is attached to a collar, as it will pull back against their throat. A harness more evenly and safely distributes weight.
What’s more, when connected to a collar, a leash doesn’t allow much control of the dog. Nervous dogs may also be able to escape from the collar by backing out of it.
Which basic dog collar should I get?
Best of the best basic dog collar
Max and Neo Nylon Dog Collar: available at Amazon
Our take: Made from durable nylon, this basic collar is comfortable and reflective, providing a safe, welcome option for most dogs.
What we like: Available in a few different colors. Features a reflective lining and simple clip fastener. Nylon is thickly constructed and reinforced with durable stitching.
What we dislike: Colors may bleed over time.
Best bang for your buck basic dog collar
Blueberry Pet Essentials Nylon Adjustable Dog Collar: available at Amazon
Our take: Simple yet high-quality basic collar from a trusted brand that comes at an affordable price.
What we like: Nylon fabric is reinforced by dense webbing for impressive longevity. Made in a range of colors and patterns. Durable D-ring. Low price.
What we dislike: May loosen when used with a leash.
Honorable mention basic dog collar
PetSafe Martingale Collar: available at Amazon and Chewy
Our take: Well-made martingale collar that allows for safe and confident training of dogs of all ages.
What we like: Features comfortable nylon and quick-release snap buttons. Designed to be used with leash; slightly tightens when the dog tries to pull. Multiple color options available.
What we dislike: Finding the right size can be tricky.
Anthony Marcusa is a writer for BestReviews. BestReviews is a product review company with a singular mission: to help simplify your purchasing decisions and save you time and money.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
