Skip to content
Collins was the only Cutler backup whom Bears fans saw through immediately. In 2010, he got his first action in Week 3 after the N.Y. <a class="runtimeTopic" data-topic-id="ORSPT000197" href="#">Giants</a> knocked Cutler out, then proceeded to get knocked out himself. He started the next week against Carolina in what has to be the worst performance ever for a winning <a class="runtimeTopic" data-topic-id="ORSPT000007" href="#">NFL</a> quarterback: no touchdowns, four interceptions, 32 yards. He didn't play again until the <a class="runtimeTopic" data-topic-id="EVSPR00003532" href="#">NFC</a> championship game, where he threw four passes, completed none and was yanked for <a class="runtimeTopic" data-topic-id="PESPT0013665" href="#">Caleb Hanie</a>. He never played in the league again.
"BETTER-THAN-CUTLER" SCALE
Before 2010: 3 out of 10
After 2010: 0 out of 10
Nuccio DiNuzzo / Chicago Tribune
Collins was the only Cutler backup whom Bears fans saw through immediately. In 2010, he got his first action in Week 3 after the N.Y. Giants knocked Cutler out, then proceeded to get knocked out himself. He started the next week against Carolina in what has to be the worst performance ever for a winning NFL quarterback: no touchdowns, four interceptions, 32 yards. He didn’t play again until the NFC championship game, where he threw four passes, completed none and was yanked for Caleb Hanie. He never played in the league again. “BETTER-THAN-CUTLER” SCALE Before 2010: 3 out of 10 After 2010: 0 out of 10
Chicago Tribune
PUBLISHED: | UPDATED:
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When the Bears take the field Sunday against St. Louis, Josh McCown will be the starting quarterback for the third time in four games. The Bears are 2-0 in his starts this year and likely would have defeated Detroit on Nov. 10 had McCown played instead of a still-injured Jay Cutler.
But before McCown’s success leads to the inevitable clamoring from Bears fans and pundits suggesting that McCown retain the starting job ahead of a healthy Cutler, let’s remind ourselves that we have a habit of overreacting to backups’ success.
With that in mind, here is a look at Bears fans’ ever-fluctuating views of the team’s non-Cutler QB as graded on the “Better-Than-Cutler” Scale.
By Jack M Silverstein, for RedEye
Want more? Discuss this article and others on RedEye Sports’ Facebook page.