Again the sports world is rattled by men behaving badly, but this time with a twist: NFL player Ray Rice tried to stay when he should have gone, while NBA team owner Bruce Levenson left despite good reasons for him to stick around.
The only good thing to be said about Rice’s case is the argument it makes for security cameras.
The 225-pound running back was cut from the Baltimore Ravens on Monday after team officials saw an elevator security camera video of Rice punching Janay Palmer — then his fiancee, now his wife — with a powerful left hook.
The Ravens’ front-office personnel could have viewed it months ago, after a video surfaced showing Rice dragging an apparently unconscious Palmer out of an elevator in Atlantic City, N.J. But NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell suspended Rice for just two games in a desperate attempt to protect the running back’s image and playing eligibility.
Amazingly, Palmer stood by Rice in a later news conference and actually apologized for whatever role she played in Rice’s downfall. This week she blamed the media in an Instagram post for her husband’s dismissal and indefinite suspension from the NFL.
Whatever may be going on in her mind, the sight of her defending Rice in light of the video gives new urgency to the countless other reported cases of abused women who stand by their men. It also makes one wonder about the countless other cases that are not reported for lack of footage from a security camera.
The case of Bruce Levenson, who has led the ownership group of the Atlanta Hawks since 2004, sends very different, yet similarly important messages. He appears to be a victim of his own honesty, punished for something that in my view has become more of a sin than it ought to be: racial candor.
He informed NBA Commissioner Adam Silver on Saturday that he intended to sell the team, ending a league investigation into an email that Levenson said he wrote. It detailed his thoughts to fellow Hawks executives on how the team could attract more white fans.
Levenson wonders, for example, whether the emphasis at games on hip-hop and gospel music, the fact that the cheerleaders are black, the kiss-cams focus on black fans and that most timeout contestants are black is a turn-off to white fans.
That may sound a lot like Donald Sterling’s famously taped rant about black people at Los Angeles Clippers games, which forced him to sell his controlling interest in the team.
But, after reading Levenson’s email, I agree with a better authority than I — former NBA star Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, who writes in a Time.com essay that “Levenson is no Donald Sterling.”
The questions Levenson raises, clumsily at times, sound reasonable in light of marketing and racial realities. “Don’t you think every corporation in America that is trying to attract a more diverse customer base,” Abdul-Jabbar writes, “is discussing how to feature more blacks or Asians or Latinos in their TV ads?”
Indeed, it is hard to tell what Levenson did that was so wrong. It seems to me that if anyone should feel insulted by his remarks it might be white people, particularly Georgia white people, whom he suggests are more nervous about diversity than whites in other NBA cities. “My theory is that the black crowd scared away the whites,” Levenson wrote, “and there are simply not enough affluent black fans to build a significant season ticket base.”
But Jason Walker, managing editor of the Hawks fan site Peachtree Hoops, blames other problems for low turnout at Hawks games, such as high prices, Atlanta’s notorious traffic jams, competition from football and baseball and, perhaps foremost, the team’s lack of a riveting superstar.
That sounds reasonable too. What troubles me most is not that Levenson raised the issues, correctly or not, but that he’s being punished for it. We need more frank discussions about race between reasonable people these days, even when some of the views expressed are wrong. That’s how misguided views get exposed and, one hopes, corrected.
Clarence Page, a member of the Tribune Editorial Board, blogs at chicagotribune.com/pagespage.
Twitter @cptime
Join in the discussion on the Chicago Tribune Editorial Board’s Facebook page or on Twitter by following @Trib_Ed_Board.
