Men’s aftershave is an essential part of any shaving routine. Aftershave helps alleviate razor burn, hydrates the skin and leaves the face feeling rejuvenated. Plus, many aftershaves — especially alcohol-based ones — are designed to prevent infection caused by bacteria in the razor.
Aftershave comes in many forms, including gels, lotions, splashes and balms. Different aftershaves have different ingredients and fragrances, which means there’s an aftershave for every occasion and individual. For a hydrating aftershave with a classic scent and a handy bottle for convenient application, check out Lather & Wood Shaving Co.’s Best After-Shave Balm.
What to know before you buy aftershave
Aftershave types
Lotions: Known for their hydrating and soothing qualities, aftershave lotions are usually scented and often contain alcohol or synthetic ingredients. Although lotions generally absorb quickly and are easy to use, the alcohol in them may lead to problems like ingrown hairs. Some cheaper aftershaves have this problem and may also irritate or dry out the skin.
Splashes: Thinner in consistency than lotions, splashes are ideal for normal skin types or when bacteria are a concern such as when using a reusable razor. Although they are harsher on the sensitive skin of the face, alcohol-based splashes are a great disinfectant. The alcohol content can also help close pores, though too much of this can lead to skin dryness or sting.
Balms: Like lotions, balms are known for their soothing, moisturizing properties. Most aftershaves are found in this form. Balms usually have little to no alcohol content and use natural ingredients. Despite this, balms can still clean the pores and kill harmful bacteria.
Alcohol or non-alcohol aftershave
If you’ve ever noticed a tingling effect when using aftershave, it’s most likely due to the alcohol base. Traditionally, alcohol was used in aftershaves as a disinfectant for barber’s blades. Nowadays, not all aftershaves use alcohol. In fact, alcohol could clog pores, cause ingrown hairs or dry out sensitive skin.
Fragrance
Not all aftershaves have a fragrance, but most do. Fragrances range from exotic and masculine to woodsy, herbal or botanical. Typically, the scent won’t impact the feel or performance of the aftershave. But it could affect your nose or those around you, especially if it’s overpowering.
Aftershave features
Natural vs. synthetic ingredients
The ingredients in aftershave impact their effect on the skin. Here are some of the more common ingredients and their purposes in aftershave:
Natural oils, aloe vera and glycerin are all used to hydrate, soothe and strengthen the skin. Some of these ingredients, like aloe vera, may even reduce minor scars over time.
Alcohol is ideal for those who need the antiseptic aspect, but it can be harmful to sensitive skin or with extended use.
Witch hazel is used to prevent irritation or dryness. It is typically found in nonalcoholic aftershaves.
Natural extracts and mineral oils provide a natural, light scent and are safe for most skin types.
Artificial scents or chemicals may result in a stronger, long-lasting fragrance but could result in a reaction upon application.
Type of application
When it comes to application, the packaging and the consistency of the aftershave matter.
Packaging: Most men’s aftershaves come in a small bottle with a convenient applicator nozzle. Depending on the consistency of the aftershave, the applicator could make it easy to apply the right amount of aftershave or cause you to use too much. Some aftershaves come in fancy or unique containers that make for great gifts.
Consistency: Splashes are watery, so they may absorb easily into the skin, but they could be messy. Balms and lotions are typically easier to spread and rub into the skin. Some aftershaves, especially those from unknown brands or of lower quality, could leave an oily residue upon application.
Main purpose
Some aftershaves are formulated with ingredients that promote healing and alleviate irritation caused by shaving. Others are primarily designed to prevent the chances of infection. Still, others mainly lend a fragrance and don’t have much of any hydrating or healing properties. Choose the aftershave that best suits your preference and needs.
Aftershave cost
The cheapest aftershaves also often have the highest alcohol content and synthetic ingredients. They range from $5 to $15. High-quality products from top brands cost anywhere from $30 to $75. For a mid-range option, expect to spend between $15 and $30.
Aftershave FAQ
How do I use aftershave?
A. Once you’ve finished shaving, rinse and dry your face. Then, coat your palms with aftershave and gently rub it into your face until it’s completely absorbed. You probably won’t need much aftershave.
Can I use aftershave with an electric shaver?
A. Aftershave can be used with any type of razor, including electric shavers, because it soothes the skin and alleviates razor burn.
Can women use aftershave?
A. It depends on the ingredients and where they intend to use it, but it is possible for women to use aftershave. However, most aftershaves are geared towards men.
Which aftershave should I get?
Best of the best aftershave
Lather & Wood Shaving Co. Best After-shave Balm: available at Amazon
Our take: Premium quality aftershave that moisturizes and soothes sensitive or irritated skin after shaving.
What we like: Non-drying aftershave with a mostly organic formula that’s gentle enough for the face and alleviates razor burn to leave the skin looking and feeling healthy. It comes in a convenient bottle that makes it easy to apply the right amount. Cruelty-free formula with minimal alcohol content.
What we dislike: The musky, sandalwood scent may be overpowering for some.
Best bang for your buck aftershave
Billy Jealousy Shaved Ice Aftershave Balm: available at Amazon
Our take: The natural mint cooling effect makes this aftershave balm ideal for men with highly sensitive skin.
What we like: Paraben-free, gel-based aftershave that uses quality ingredients to give you a refreshing, salon-like feel when you shave. Formulated to prevent ingrown hairs, alleviate irritation caused by shaving and restore the skin’s natural pH balance. Has a pleasant herbal, citrus and botanical scent.
What we dislike: The thick, gel-like consistency doesn’t wash off easily. Some customers found the cooling effect didn’t work as well as advertised.
Honorable mention aftershave
Musgo Real After Shave Balm: available at Amazon
Our take: With natural ingredients that hydrate and soothe the skin, this aftershave is best for those with dry, flaky or sensitive skin.
What we like: Classic aftershave with shea butter for ultimate moisturization and healthier skin. This balm absorbs quickly into the skin and leaves behind a mild but masculine scent.
What we dislike: The fragrance is very light and not for everyone’s body chemistry.
Honorable mention aftershave
Calvin Klein Obsession Aftershave Balm: available at Amazon and Macy’s
Our take: Soothing aftershave from a recognized brand that soothes and hydrates the skin without the burn of alcohol.
What we like: This aftershave promotes healthy skin after a shave. Plus, it has a classic fragrance that isn’t overpowering, making it a great complement to any shaving routine.
What we dislike: Consistency is a little thin, so it’s easy to squeeze too much out from the bottle. Scent isn’t long-lasting and may be too musky for some users.
Honorable mention aftershave
Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm: available at Amazon
Our take: Dermatologist-tested aftershave balm specifically formulated for men with sensitive skin.
What we like: Free from harmful dyes and drying alcohol, this balm hydrates the skin with ingredients like Vitamin E and soothing chamomile extracts for a healthy glow. Nonirritating formula that soothes burns and nicks caused by the blade.
What we dislike: Scent is too mild for some customers. The product is not always packaged well.
Angela Watson is a writer for BestReviews. BestReviews is a product review company with a singular mission: to help simplify your purchasing decisions and save you time and money.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
